11 Comments
User's avatar
Hilary May's avatar

I visited the wonderful Nant y Bedd garden in S Wales last year and the owners (whose name I’ve forgotten) talk about editing rather than weeding - I liked the idea!

Linda Wood-Thomas's avatar

I've been experimenting with leaving my weeds too Jack. I'm in the New Forest, Hampshire. We didn't have any rain for months last summer and this year is looking to be the same. I had noticed that in areas where I had weeded around plants, the plants started to wilt and look very stressed.

Jack Wallington's avatar

Very interesting Linda- such important feedback, thank you. I’m very interested in experiences further south from us where the drought is worse.

DRNaturegirl's avatar

I’ve left some chickweed around my beans this year and they seem to be doing OK. My main bed with perennials has a lot of weeds but I think I’ll remove the dock at least as the plants aren’t well established yet.

Jack Wallington's avatar

Your thinking seems spot on! Same As what I do, I have chickweed beneath our tomatoes where it’s largely helpful if it doesn’t get too dense - and edible itself! I do remove dock as it is just too vigorous and would be detrimental in some areas.

DRNaturegirl's avatar

Phew! Something must be sinking in then! Thanks for all the useful advice and plain sense! 🙂

Jack Wallington's avatar

I think you've got it :)

Sharon Moncur's avatar

This is so interesting, Jack. My instinct (and practice to date, esp in SWFrance where turn your back for a moment and a head high forest of ash trees … etc … has grown) is quite different. Not disagreeing as such as I can see the validity of many of your points … but … could I do it … ??!

Jack Wallington's avatar

You do have to remove the bigger plants, I remove nettles and brambles, and would remove tree seedlings otherwise they take over. You have to decide where your line is 😄

Shirley Broughton's avatar

Thank you. Couldn't agree more!! Love it.

Jack Wallington's avatar

I really enjoy it, even if the garden doesn't look as immaculate - I prefer the look even if others don't :D